MLU FORUM

MLU FORUM (http://www.mapleleafup.net/forums/index.php)
-   The Gun Park (http://www.mapleleafup.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   Coastal Defence Guns (http://www.mapleleafup.net/forums/showthread.php?t=19690)

David Dunlop 22-01-13 16:33

Coastal Defence Guns
 
Were coastal defence guns in Canada during WW2 modified naval guns, modified field guns or a unique category of gun all their own?

alamotex 22-01-13 16:59

1 Attachment(s)
Attachment 54312

Your best bet would be to borrow a copy of GUNNERS IN CANADA by Nicholson. I recall that he covers this topic. Hopefully aerial image of 9 inch gun emplacement attached.

Brian

Bob Carriere 23-01-13 02:25

How about these shore guns in Gaspe....
 
3 Attachment(s)
Only two left at the mouth of the Gaspe basin..... not sure but believe they were naval guns.

Bob

Robert Bergeron 23-01-13 16:20

Coastal defense
 
Bob,

Are those in Fort Prével near Gaspé Québec ?

Been there.

Robert :no4:

Mark W. Tonner 23-01-13 19:58

Re: coastal defence guns in Canada
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by David Dunlop (Post 174828)
Were coastal defence guns in Canada during WW2 modified naval guns, modified field guns or a unique category of gun all their own?

David;

The following well give you an idea of what was used on Canada's Pacific coast: Army Headquarters (AHQ) Report No. 1 - Fixed Coast Artillery Defences on the Pacific Coast, dated 8 May 1944, located here: http://www.cmp-cpm.forces.gc.ca/dhh-...qga/ahq001.pdf, which was compiled by the staff of the General Staff Historical Section, National Defence Headquarters, Ottawa.

Cheers

Mark W. Tonner 23-01-13 20:23

Re: coastal defence guns in Canada
 
David;

Further reading on Canadian coastal defences (Atlantic and Pacific), can be found in Chapter 5 - Defending the soil of Canada, 1939-1945, of the Official History of the Canadian Army in the Second World War, Volume I: Six Years of War, which is located here: http://www.cmp-cpm.forces.gc.ca/dhh-...s/Sixyrs_e.pdf

Cheers

servicepub (RIP) 24-01-13 02:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark W. Tonner (Post 174879)
David;

The following well give you an idea of what was used on Canada's Pacific coast: Army Headquarters (AHQ) Report No. 1 - Fixed Coast Artillery Defences on the Pacific Coast, dated 8 May 1944, located here: http://www.cmp-cpm.forces.gc.ca/dhh-...qga/ahq001.pdf, which was compiled by the staff of the General Staff Historical Section, National Defence Headquarters, Ottawa.

Cheers

The above report was re-worked and published last year in the Weapons of War series. Available from www.servicepub.com

http://www.servicepub.com/images/pac...st%20cover.jpg

Bob Carriere 24-01-13 03:21

Reply to Robert B.
 
Yes they are........ small display but very impressive. Not well advertised and as usual played down.

I never realized that the Gaspe basin was intended to be used as a back up refuge for the Royal Navy fleet should England be invaded..... shared with Halifax Bedford basin.

They had anti submarine steel nets controlling access to the basin..... a seaplane base....... saddely most of the original installations have been leveled for urban development.

ships coming in had to stop in a holding area, well within range of the shore guns, ships IDed, searched and cleared for entrance in the basin. Even local folks remember very little of that period.

Bob

Mike Cecil 24-01-13 03:28

Bag Loading (BL): 'BL' is Breech Loading.

The weapon type uses bag charges, ie does not use a complete cartridge case (as in QF: Quick Firing).

Mike C

Bob Carriere 24-01-13 03:45

For sure they where not.....
 
Muzzle loading................

Mike Cecil 24-01-13 05:31

In short, the two terms encapsulate a number of different things:

BL = Breech Loading . These use a Bag Charge. eg M198 155mm; 5.5inch BL. and are loaded into the gun separately: projectile first, then the bag charge. The primer tube is also separate. Variation of propellant charge is possible at the gun by varying the number of Charge Bags that make up the Bag Charge (in most cases).

QF = Quick Firing where the means of obturation is by the rapid expansion of the cartridge case against the wall of the breech. There are three types of ammunition for QF guns:
(1) Fixed: these are fixed at the factory, and do not use Charge Bags (note: not a 'Bag Charge') Eg :18pdr QF, 20pdr QF Tank, 105mm Tank, etc
(2) semi-fixed: these arrive at the gun in two parts: cart case with charge bags and a projectile. They are mated once the correct number of charge bags have been removed (if any), and then loaded as a single cartridge, eg 105mm M101A1 (viz M2A2)
(3) separate: these arrive at the gun line separately, and once the correct number of charge bags are removed (if any) then the projectile is rammed into the chamber using the Rammer, then the cart case loaded, ie both components are loaded into the gun separately. eg 25-pdr QF.

Semi fixed and separate QF ammunition are a means to allow variations to the propellant charge at the gun.

QF and BL guns both load into the breech, but use a different means of obturation (simply, the means of preventing the propellant gases escaping to the rear).

Mike C

Mark W. Tonner 24-01-13 13:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by servicepub (Post 174901)
The above report was re-worked and published last year in the Weapons of War series.

. . . I knew that . . . :D


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 02:52.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Maple Leaf Up, 2003-2016