I would give second thought to paint that is too flat.
My most recent project was sprayed in 'lusterless olive drab' 34087 and looks nice. The problem is that it shows every boot mark and scuff - it cleans up nice because it is CARC, but if I were to be able to do it again I would have chosen a darker semi-gloss.
And it would look less jeep like ( although it was made at the jeep plant in MA ).
BTW - I ordered a taillamp from Markup at Willys Acres last December, and have not seen ( or heard from him ) since my cheque cleared the bank.
Stewart