Thread: American Sniper
View Single Post
  #8  
Old 22-01-15, 18:42
jdmcm's Avatar
jdmcm jdmcm is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Surrey, BC, CDN
Posts: 672
Default

Saw American Sniper...also read the book...Eastwood did a great job, I think Bradley Cooper is awesome, despite the animatronic baby...It is the strange cult of personality that surrounds Chris Kyle that I still find disturbing. Equally disturbing is Eastwood's decision to steer clear of the many and documented controversies.

Kyle had stated:

1. He had been the victim of an attempted car jacking in Texas post-war, but instead of relinquishing his vehicle he shot both assailants dead in highway truck stop, when the police arrived, Kyle provided a phone number to them to call. The person on the other end told the police that Kyle was basically "off limits" and "hero"...the police returned his weapon and let him go on the spot...

Unfortunately the incident never took place, both the New Yorker and Vanity Fair magazine canvassed the state of Texas including all the law enforcement agencies who could have possibly been involved...no police statements, no witnesses, no gas station surveillance video, no bodies

2. Kyle said himself and another Navy Seal were dispatched to New Orleans in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. Kyle claimed that he personally had shot and killed over 30 American civilians from a rooftop in order to restore order

When asked about this by investigators, the military said emphatically "NO" navy seals had been sent to New Orleans and the story of the murder of 30 US citizens..."defied imagination"

3. Kyle stated and wrote in his book that he had "punched out" former Minnesota governor and ex-UDT Diver, Jesse Ventura for talking ill of the Seals and the war in Iraq. He repeated this claim on his book tour...

except this too was proven in a court of law to be a lie. Ventura won a 1.8 million dollar defamation suit against Kyle, who's own deposition was wrought full of lies, inconsistencies and factual errors

Great movie in the vein of entertainment, but the fact that they were too scared or too blinded by some type of jingoistic bend to make the war in Iraq into some type of noble crusade, they failed to portray the man, who was obviously a deeply flawed person well before he became an "American Sniper". Now that he is dead, his legend becomes untouchable and any attempt to get to the truth becomes and attack on patriotism.

One thumb up for great filmaking in the vein of Rambo...One thumb WAY down for honesty
Reply With Quote