Cracked engine block repair question?

[Blackpowder44 (RIP)]

I have to say again, DO NOT WELD, your cast block is 70 odd years old, if you heat the block up to the temperature required to weld up the crack it will have an adverse effect on the steel on either side of the crack and when the weld cools down it will contract only very slightly nbut this can cause the metal on either side of the crack to itsself crack in time.The stiching method causes no stress to the surrounding metal, can be finished off with a flapper disc and once painted, no sign of the crack. Great scab of welding or brasing looks like shyte and if as you say your enging is a really good one why ruin it by welding. I know this sounds like a rant, but in the last 40 years I have seen too many engines with this scabs of welding. Also you have to pay someone to do the welding whereas you can stich the block yourself. HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH WELDING OR ANY CRAP PUT INTO THE WATER TO BLOCK UP THE CRACK,please take on board what I have said, good luck, John.

[Blackpowder44 (RIP)]

Google, Stiching a cracked engine block,all the info there, please please do not weld, John.

[Eric B]

I had several GPW engines, which were magnofluxed to see if they were any good. Once we found one that was right it was sent for welding.

It was welded ok, but unfortunetly for me the mechanic assembled the engine wrong.(A neighbour/friend who owned his own business).

After driving with a knocking noise for several years i went to another mechanic and engine shop. They not only found issues with the assembly and the welding but also more block issues.

In the end we stripped the engine and it was sent out to a specialist in welding blocks. They did a fantastic job. All of the holes were filled and redrilled. It looks like a new engine with no sign of any welding.

The GPW blocks are known to crack and some of the blocks had issues even when new. The Willys blocks have a better lifespan.

Unless you are a mechanic yourself, send it off to a professional and get it done right the first time. (I thought i had done that).

Word of mouth is the best source.

It turns out my professional engine rebuilders father worked on Jeep engines in WW2.

Anybody in the Ottawa area should have no issues dealing with West Carleton Automtive. I highly recommend them.

Welding is not an issue, unless not done right.

Eric

[Blackpowder44 (RIP)]

Originally Posted by Eric B

I had several GPW engines, which were magnofluxed to see if they were any good. Once we found one that was right it was sent for welding.

It was welded ok, but unfortunetly for me the mechanic assembled the engine wrong.(A neighbour/friend who owned his own business).

After driving with a knocking noise for several years i went to another mechanic and engine shop. They not only found issues with the assembly and the welding but also more block issues.

In the end we stripped the engine and it was sent out to a specialist in welding blocks. They did a fantastic job. All of the holes were filled and redrilled. It looks like a new engine with no sign of any welding.

The GPW blocks are known to crack and some of the blocks had issues even when new. The Willys blocks have a better lifespan.

Unless you are a mechanic yourself, send it off to a professional and get it done right the first time. (I thought i had done that).

Word of mouth is the best source.

It turns out my professional engine rebuilders father worked on Jeep engines in WW2.

Anybody in the Ottawa area should have no issues dealing with West Carleton Automtive. I highly recommend them.

Welding is not an issue, unless not done right.

Eric

yes it is read the google info.John

[elvis3006]

Guys thank you for the help/info. i will check things out and do the right thing.